top of page

Collagen: Making the Ethical Choice

Updated: Dec 11, 2023

Collagen peptides

Click here for our latest update on collagen peptides!

You can find collagen in almost everything these days, from powders and protein bars to collagen water (yum?).

So what exactly is collagen, and what does it do?

Collagen is the main structural protein found in the skin and other connective tissues.

  1. Collagen is a hard, insoluble, and fibrous protein that makes up one-third of the protein in the human body.

  2. It gives skin strength and elasticity.

  3. There are at least 16 different types of collagen, but 80 to 90 percent of them belong to types 1, 2, and 3. These different types have different structures and functions.

  4. Collagen is secreted by various cells, but mainly by connective tissue cells.

  5. It is found in the extracellular matrix. This is an intricate network of macromolecules that determines the physical properties of body tissues. A macromolecule is a molecule containing a large number of atoms.

  6. With age, collagen weakens, leading to wrinkles and cartilage problems.

  7. In the dermis or the middle layer of skin, collagen helps form a fibrous network of cells called fibroblasts, upon which new cells can grow. It also plays a role in replacing and restoring dead skin cells.

  8. Some collagens act as protective coverings for delicate organs in the body, such as the kidneys.

  9. With age, the body produces less collagen. The structural integrity of the skin declines, wrinkles form, and joint cartilage weakens.

  10. Women experience a dramatic reduction in collagen synthesis after menopause.

  11. By the age of 60 years, a considerable decline in collagen production is normal.

Layers of the skin

When choosing a collagen supplement, there are many important factors that must be taken into account: ethics, sourcing, quality control, processing, and the composition of the final product.

While most people believe that collagen supplements are made from bones or other edible parts of an animal, the vast majority of collagen supplements are actually made from the inedible and indigestible parts of animals like the hide of cows or the scales of fish.

These parts are very cheap for companies to buy, allowing them to make a huge profit while charging you a premium price for materials they get for next to nothing.

This heavy processing essentially yields a powdered blend of amino acids, far from the whole food or natural product claims that most companies make.

Without this heavy processing, it would not mix well into cold beverages because many of the naturally occurring compounds are not water-soluble. Real bone broth collagen (most "bone broth" powders are not real bone broth) is a great option for looking for a powdered product.

Collagen Peptide Powder

Some companies claim to use parts from grass-fed animals, although many are derived from regular feed-lot cattle.

While grass-fed is generally better for you and the environment, a product that is so processed and only has a few isolated amino acids left is not going to provide any of the normal health benefits associated with grass-fed animal products because all of the other compounds have been removed during the heavy processing.

There are two main sources of collagen products (a few collagen products are derived from chicken sternums, but this represents a very small part of the market).

The first is conventional feedlot cattle hides from the United States.

We all know the problems of the use of factory farms in the United States, such as animal welfare, environmental issues, and human health.

Guess who the number one seller of this type of collagen in the United States is?

CLOROX, the bleach company!

They own the Neocell brand (as well as Rainbow Light vitamins, Renew Life, and Natural Vitality, the makers of Natural Calm magnesium):

Neocell collagen

The second is pastured and grass-fed cattle hides from Brazil.

While grass-fed cattle are usually better for the health of the animals, the environment, and people, in this case, it is most certainly not.

In Brazil, massive amounts of the Amazon rainforest are being cut down to make room for cattle to graze. This is creating an environmental catastrophe.

Cattle ranching is responsible for almost 80% of the deforestation rates of the Amazon. Many of the massive fires being set there are to make grazing land for cattle.

The rainforest is far too important to all of humanity and the native peoples who live there to be cut down for short-term profits. Once it is gone, we can never get it back.

Boycotting all beef products from Brazil is one of the easiest ways to help preserve the rainforest.

No matter how good the quality of a product is, if it creates profound ethical or environmental issues, is it really worth it?

Martin Luther King Quote

Guess who now owns the number one company selling collagen products from Brazil?

Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides

Remember, Nestle already owns the following vitamin companies already:

  1. Garden of Life

  2. Pure Encapsulations

  3. Douglas Labs

  4. Minami

  5. Genestra

  6. Seroyal

  7. Persona

  8. Solgar

  9. Natures Bounty

  10. Sundown

  11. Puritans Pride

  12. Ester-C

  13. Osteo Bi-Flex

  14. Wobenzyme

  15. Orgain

  16. And a lot more!

There is no reason you should have to compromise your ethics, health, or the environment to get good collagen or any other supplement.

Boycott Nestle, Nestle Free Zone

Rooted Nutrition has proudly always been and always will be a Nestle-free zone!

It comes from grass-fed cows that graze on lush pastures.

These pastures exist without the need to clear-cut forests to create them.

The cows are not pumped full of hormones and antibiotics.

The animals come from a country with strict animal welfare and environmental laws that are actually enforced. It should also have laws that ensure farmworkers are paid a fair wage and are treated well.

When looking for a country that met all of these ethical requirements, New Zealand and Australia were the only ones that actually checked all the boxes on our ethics checklist. The other countries that met these requirements did not produce the whole-food collagen that we were looking for.

Australian Cattle, Collagen

How is a true whole-food collagen supplement made?

Real whole-food collagen is minimally processed. It should be made from whole, edible animal parts - not scales and hides. It is not acid washed, bleached, demineralized, or ion-exchanged. It should be tested to ensure it is free of BSE (commonly known as mad cow disease). Australia and New Zealand have never had BSE, whereas Brazil recently has had cases. It should also be tested to ensure it is free of herbicides, pesticides, and fungicides.

It should be tested to ensure it does not contain high levels of heavy metals like lead, arsenic, and cadmium. Many collagen supplements actually have a problem with heavy metal contamination.

The collagen should be traceable from the farm where the cows were raised to the processing facility and finally to the factory where the product is bottled.

Protease, an enzyme, is applied to remove the non-cartilage parts of the materials while in water and dried at low temperatures.

Nothing is added, and nothing is taken away.

That’s it. Much much different from conventional collagen products.

It was incredibly difficult to find collagen products that were truly whole food, as opposed to just claiming to be.

A whole-food collagen product should contain all the naturally occurring compounds present in the whole food, not just a few amino acids. Some of these compounds, depending on which type of collagen it is, include:

  1. Collagens

  2. Amino acids

  3. Bioactive Growth Factors: IGF-1, TGFßI & Cartilage Derived Growth Factor (CDGF)

  4. Glycosaminoglycans | Proteoglycans

  5. Chondroitin Sulfates

  6. Much more

When you use heavily processed and refined collagen products, you lose out on nearly all of these wonderful compounds and their benefits.

White bread versus whole wheat bread

Why take the collagen equivalent of white bread and miss out on all of the benefits true whole-food collagen has to offer?

There are different types of collagen. Each has different uses. Type 1 is best for bone health. Type 2 is best for joint and immune health. A blend of types 1 and 3 is best for hair, skin, and nails. Types 5 and 1 are best for gut health.

Ethics and quality permeate every part of what we do at Rooted Nutrition. We truly believe that you cannot have one without the other. We will never force you to make that choice.

If we find out that one of the companies or products we sell starts doing things that affect quality or ethics, we will stop selling them. We do not have loyalty to any brand or company.

If you wish to learn more about collagen, on everything from how it's made to which one might be best for you, our collagen center is the place for you.

We are so proud and excited to be able to offer you whole-food collagen supplements that support your health without compromise! Check them out.


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page